Andrew Ducker (andrewducker) wrote,
Andrew Ducker
andrewducker

Why Labour is at war with itself

I've been watching the fun and games around the Labour election at the moment, and how incredibly emotional it's getting, both from people who hate what Labour has become (and hope Corbyn can rescue it from that), and from people who believe that a left-wing Labour will never get elected (and will thus settle for any electable party that's to the left of the Conservatives).

And this is really tearing Labour apart, to the point where MPs are plotting a coup if he wins.

And the one thing that's _really_ obvious to me is that this is all the fault of the electoral system. If we had a proportionate electoral system then at some point either the centre ground would have split off (presumably in the 90s) or the left-wing would have split off (presumably in the 2000s), and we'd have two reasonably sized "Left of the Conservatives" parties, which would give voters a choice of who they supported in each election, and where they wanted the government to go.

As it is, we're stuck with parties constantly at war with each other - and frequently at war with their base, as most of the MPs want a party that wins elections, and the base want a party that represents their views.



Original post on Dreamwidth - there are comment count unavailable comments there.
Subscribe

  • Holiday Photos and Julie News

    We are on holiday for two weeks. Which is basically four days with Julies family in Northern Ireland, and then eight days with my family in the Lake…

  • Hopefully just a brief blip in Julie's recovery

    About two years ago, Julie was diagnosed with cancer. Her Bcr-Abl levels at the time were just over 100. At each three-monthly meeting with her…

  • So, what's going on with me?

    Any update about me starts off, of course, with Julie, because my mood is rather contingent upon her well-being. Shortly before going on holiday[1]…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 56 comments

  • Holiday Photos and Julie News

    We are on holiday for two weeks. Which is basically four days with Julies family in Northern Ireland, and then eight days with my family in the Lake…

  • Hopefully just a brief blip in Julie's recovery

    About two years ago, Julie was diagnosed with cancer. Her Bcr-Abl levels at the time were just over 100. At each three-monthly meeting with her…

  • So, what's going on with me?

    Any update about me starts off, of course, with Julie, because my mood is rather contingent upon her well-being. Shortly before going on holiday[1]…