Andrew Ducker (andrewducker) wrote,
Andrew Ducker

What I don't like about voice control

I was chatting to Nick about voice control on the Kinect/XBox One - and the fact that when either of us is alone we don't tend to speak much, if at all - so the thought of talking to the machinery feels very odd.

And I realised the other reason I don't like it - the failure mode of typing is that I hit a wrong key, with a recovery action of "stare at the keyboard and make sure I press the right one next" but the failure mode of voice control is that nothing happens, and the recovery mode is "Try again repeatedly, with no real idea of what you need to do differently to make it work".

I find "things not doing what they're supposed to" incredibly frustrating - it's one of the main drivers of my computing knowledge - struggling for ages with computers, until I've fixed whatever the problem was, is a great way to learn how they work. But a voice interface is mushy and vague, it's not something I _can_ understand without seeing all sorts of diagnostics which just aren't available to the users. Which, largely, means it's just not for me.

Original post on Dreamwidth - there are comment count unavailable comments there.

  • Interesting Links for 27-02-2021

    Covid in Scotland: 40-49 next to be vaccinated (including me!) (tags: vaccination Scotland pandemic age ) Cairngorms recreated in Minecraft…

  • Interesting Links for 26-02-2021

    Why do video games matter? 20 books every player should read (tags: games books ) Trying to weed out the good criticisms of Scott…

  • Interesting Links for 25-02-2021

    '10-year prison sentences for breaching COVID-19 entry requirements into the United Kingdom'. How Governmental Decree is undermining the Rule of…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened