We'll definitely be going for Borderlands 2 first, as the first one was the most fun I've had in a game in a long time. Good to have Torchlight 2 as backup though.
In other gaming news, Black Mesa: Source was just released. A recreation of the first 3/4 of Half-Life, but with massively upgraded graphics, it's free, and from my experience of the first ten minutes, superbly well done. If you've never played Half-Life (or haven't played it in a while) then make your way here and download it (I grabbed it as a torrent and had it very quickly). It's free, so now you have no excuse! (You can go here to watch the trailer, say "ooooh" at how awesome it looks first, if you like.)
Original post on Dreamwidth - there are comments there.