Andrew Ducker (andrewducker) wrote,
Andrew Ducker
andrewducker

That would be a political question

Taking for (vague) definitions:
A democratic system increases the amount that the will of the people matters.
An effective system is one that puts smart/informed in charge to make things happen.
A system that maximises freedom enshrines certain rights so that they can't be changed even if the people don't like them.

Which would you prefer the system to prioritise?

I would prefer my political system to maximise

democracy
2(3.7%)
effectiveness
17(31.5%)
freedom
16(29.6%)
SEWIWEIC
19(35.2%)


At the moment we in the UK obviously have a hotch-potch. Representative democracy means that we elect (theoretically) informed people to one chamber to carry out our wishes, within a framework laid down by human rights legislation. And we also appoint people to a second chamber to make sure the first lot are doing their job well. Given that the democracy for the house of commons is demonstrably rubbish, and the democracy in the House Of Lords is basically lacking, our system clearly priorities effectiveness over democracy, with a side-order of whining that we're forced to obey any human rights legislation at all.
Subscribe

  • Interesting Links for 05-03-2021

    European Parliament Postpones Brexit Deal Vote Amid Fury Over The UK's Northern Ireland Protocol Plan I mean, normally you wait for a deal to be…

  • instagram cross-post

    A nice walk. Bit chilly, but good to stretch our legs along the Water of Leith Original is here on instagram. Original post on Dreamwidth…

  • Interesting Links for 04-03-2021

    Cuttlefish can delay gratification (tags: psychology fish ) UK announces it will unilaterally change Brexit deal with EU, risking new…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 135 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →

  • Interesting Links for 05-03-2021

    European Parliament Postpones Brexit Deal Vote Amid Fury Over The UK's Northern Ireland Protocol Plan I mean, normally you wait for a deal to be…

  • instagram cross-post

    A nice walk. Bit chilly, but good to stretch our legs along the Water of Leith Original is here on instagram. Original post on Dreamwidth…

  • Interesting Links for 04-03-2021

    Cuttlefish can delay gratification (tags: psychology fish ) UK announces it will unilaterally change Brexit deal with EU, risking new…