Andrew Ducker (andrewducker) wrote,
Andrew Ducker
andrewducker

I think I'm against a Devo-Max entry on the referendum

Two reasons:
1) It wouldn't confuse me, but I've seen plenty of evidence that even the simplest question is going to confuse _some_ people, and I'd rather keep something as important as an independence referendum as simple as possible.

2) I don't think it's necessary. The negotiation of powers inside a United Kingdom is an ongoing process. We have, for instance, The Scotland Bill, which is making its way through parliament at the moment. There will always be back and forth and renegotiation, and I'd expect any government (both Scottish and UK) to push things in the direction that they feel is best. If Scots want more powers then they can vote for a party that will push harder that way*. If they want to align more closely with Westminster then they can vote for a party that will streamline things in that direction. It's not a Big Bang change, and thus doesn't need a referendum.

Between the two of them I think I'm pretty-much convinced. Any arguments on the other side?


*I mean, does anyone think that the SNP could be in power and _not_ constantly push for more powers for Scotland?



Original post on Dreamwidth - there are comment count unavailable comments there.
Subscribe

  • Interesting Links for 28-02-2021

    Single Covid case puts New Zealand's largest city Auckland back into lockdown (tags: pandemic newzealand ) Do you like it when things in your…

  • Interesting Links for 27-02-2021

    Covid in Scotland: 40-49 next to be vaccinated (including me!) (tags: vaccination Scotland pandemic age ) Cairngorms recreated in Minecraft…

  • Interesting Links for 26-02-2021

    Why do video games matter? 20 books every player should read (tags: games books ) Trying to weed out the good criticisms of Scott…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 51 comments

  • Interesting Links for 28-02-2021

    Single Covid case puts New Zealand's largest city Auckland back into lockdown (tags: pandemic newzealand ) Do you like it when things in your…

  • Interesting Links for 27-02-2021

    Covid in Scotland: 40-49 next to be vaccinated (including me!) (tags: vaccination Scotland pandemic age ) Cairngorms recreated in Minecraft…

  • Interesting Links for 26-02-2021

    Why do video games matter? 20 books every player should read (tags: games books ) Trying to weed out the good criticisms of Scott…