Andrew Ducker (andrewducker) wrote,
Andrew Ducker
andrewducker

Art and Computer games

If we take as a starting point that art is "a designed experience which evokes emotion*", then I think that most games focus on "excitement" as the only emotion they care about.  As most highbrow people would tend to look down on that particular emotion, it's not going to persuade them over computer games artiness.

Most games don't go much further than that - but I've certainly been made happy, sad, afraid, and thoroughly involved by computer games.  They haven't, generally, been as good as movies at doing so, because excitement is so much easier for computer games designers to focus on, and the bits which produce other emotions tend to be quite filmlike or booklike (depending on whether they are produced by reading dialogue or watching a cut-scene).

My definition du jour of "game" is "a process which provides a challenge for a person to overcome".  If you're choosing between options which provide multiple equally "good" solutions (i.e. dialogue trees that don't affect your success level), are they really part of the game?  So we're left with two parts of computer games - the bits which are challenges to be overcome (which can produce excitement and feelings of achievement), and the bits which are evoking other emotions.  If you exclude those two emotions from the range which count as proper art then computer games are a mixture of interactive art and game, without any crossover.  If you do include them, then games are definitely art.

If, of course, your definitions of "art" and "games" are different to mine, which they probably will be, as I only made mine up half an hour ago, then your conclusions will be different.  There are a bunch of definitions of "game" <A href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game#Definitions">here</A> and art <A href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art#Definition_of_the_term">here</A>.
Subscribe

  • Interesting Links for 05-03-2021

    European Parliament Postpones Brexit Deal Vote Amid Fury Over The UK's Northern Ireland Protocol Plan I mean, normally you wait for a deal to be…

  • instagram cross-post

    A nice walk. Bit chilly, but good to stretch our legs along the Water of Leith Original is here on instagram. Original post on Dreamwidth…

  • Interesting Links for 04-03-2021

    Cuttlefish can delay gratification (tags: psychology fish ) UK announces it will unilaterally change Brexit deal with EU, risking new…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 34 comments

  • Interesting Links for 05-03-2021

    European Parliament Postpones Brexit Deal Vote Amid Fury Over The UK's Northern Ireland Protocol Plan I mean, normally you wait for a deal to be…

  • instagram cross-post

    A nice walk. Bit chilly, but good to stretch our legs along the Water of Leith Original is here on instagram. Original post on Dreamwidth…

  • Interesting Links for 04-03-2021

    Cuttlefish can delay gratification (tags: psychology fish ) UK announces it will unilaterally change Brexit deal with EU, risking new…